Top Sump Pump for Homeowners

Having a top sump pump in your basement or crawl space is your first line of defense against a damaging flood in your home. It’s important to choose the best sump pump by comparing the power, styles, warranty and efficiency of the sump pump models on the market. Read on to learn more:

And you can check out my #1 recommended sump pump for homeowners: the Zoeller M53 Mighty Mate on Amazon.

The most important thing to consider is how much horsepower (HP) and Gallons per Hour (GPH) you’ll want when you’re choosing the top sump pump for your home. You don’t want to choose a pump with too little power because it can get overwhelmed with flood water – and you’ll still have flooding. Or it will burn itself out trying to keep up with the demand.

I highly recommend the Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate Submersible Sump Pump with 1/3HP, on Amazon, as the best submersible sump pump value for homeowners.  

Here’s why: the 1/3HP motor size is the right power size for the average sized home & it makes little to no noise when it’s running. And this Zoeller M53 sump pump has a high quality cast iron switch case, motor and pump housing. 

The Zoeller M53 will pump a maximum of 2,580 gallons per hour. It’s a workhorse!

Check Amazon’s price on the Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate.

And you don’t want to choose a top sump pump with too much horsepower, because you’ll be paying more for power that you simply don’t need. If you’re like me, I hate to waste my hard earned money.

I always recommend that homeowners choose a sump pump with a 1/3 to ½ horsepower rating. In fact, pumps with a 1/3 to ½ HP rating are the most popular size pumps sold. You’ll have more than enough HP and GPH power for an average sized home, but you’ll still get a competitive price on a top sump pump.

What is the purpose of a top sump pump?

You may be asking “what is the purpose of a top sump pump” and “who needs a sump pump”?

The purpose of a sump pump in your home, is to remove accumulating water in your basement. If you’re located in an area that has a naturally high ground water level, or you have heavy rains & storms, you need a sump pump.

And don’t forget, if you live in an area that has a lot of snow melt, a sump pump comes to the rescue again.

Here's my handy sump pump comparison chart:

Your sump pump will remove the water from your basement or crawl space and discharge it to a dry well or sewer/storm drain.


New Articles on this Page:

Top Sump Pump Backup System

Best Pedestal Sump Pump


Pedestal Sump Pump vs Submersible Style Sump Pump

compare pedestal to submersible sump pumps

There is an ongoing debate over a pedestal sump pump vs submersible pumps. When you’re shopping around to choose the top sump pump for your home & budget, you’ll notice that there are two major designs: pedestal vs submersible.

Simply put, a pedestal sump pump is positioned above the sump basin, generally on the basement floor. It's a non submersible sump pump style.  In contrast, a submersible pump is fully installed in the sump basin, below the level of your basement floor.

It’s easier to do repairs and maintenance on a pedestal sump pump, because it sits above the sump pit. And it’s exposed. But, it’s also easier to damage a pedestal sump pump unit by accidentally knocking into it. This is especially true if you have kids or dogs.

I can recommend the Flotec FPPM3600D 1/3 HP Pedestal Sump Pump on Amazon.

This pedestal style sump pump will pump up to 3,480 gallons per hour (GPH), is designed with a non-clogging impeller and has a top screen inlet with 1.25” discharge. The Flotec FPPM3600D has both thermoplastic and cast iron construction with an 6 foot, 3 prong cord/plug.

And you can check Amazon’s price on the Flotec FPPM3600D Pedestal Sump Pump.

And while doing repairs or maintenance to a submersible top sump pump involves more work, because you will need to remove the pump from the basin/pit, by digging it up.

But I want to point out that a submersible pump is a much quieter pump! The noise of the motor in a submersible pump is dampened because it’s submerged in the pit – so there is little to no noise when it’s running.

It’s important to know this, when you’re comparing top sump pumps, because pedestal sump pumps are very noisy. And some pedestal pumps can be heard all over the house.

You can see my top recommended quiet submersible sump pump: the Zoeller M53 Mighty-Mate available on Amazon.

Best Sump Pump Backup System

Aside from choosing the top sump pump suited for your home and budget, you’ll also want to invest in the best sump pump backup system. Why? Because, if you power goes out, or your primary sump pump fails, or it’s overwhelmed, you need a battery backup sump pump to take over. And avoid a damaging flood.

I can strongly recommend the Basement Watchdog BWE Emergency Back-up Sump pump on Amazon.

When your primary sump pump fails, is overwhelmed, clogs or wears out, the Basement Watchdog BWE  automatically starts up to pump up to 1,000 gallons per hour (GPH) at 10 ft lift and 2,000 GPH at 0 feet lift! It stands watch over your basement to make sure it doesn’t become a swimming pool.

What I REALLY love about the Basement Watchdog is that it has a unique LED control panel that actually tells you what’s wrong with your primary sump pump – and what to do to fix it! Genius.

And you can check Amazon’s price on the Basement Watchdog.

We all know that there’s a risk of our utility power going out when there’s a big storm. And, don't forget, if there’s a really big storm or snow melt, your primary pump may need a helping hand.

A sump pump battery backup immediately senses when your top sump pump has become overwhelmed by rising sump water. And your sump pump backup system will automatically kick on. Even if you're not home, I like to think of a battery backup sump pump as standing guard, ready to help.

A sump pump backup system is a fairly inexpensive way to ensure that you won’t come home to a flooded basement.

You can read more of my tips for choosing the best battery backup for a sump pump by Click Here.

If you'd like some more tips for choosing the best sump pump, you can check out this video from North Dakota State University:


Popular Articles on this Page:

Quick Sump Pump Comparison Chart

Zoeller M53 Sump Pump Review


Ejector Pump vs Sump Pump

differences between an ejector pump vs sump pump

Have you looked around your basement and saw what you thought were two submersible sump pumps? Like the photo above?

Well, they do look the same, but what you really have is one ejector pump and one sump pump. They're actually two different pumps - for two entirely different uses in your home.

An ejector pump, or sewage ejector pump, takes care of pumping out dirty water from your basement bathroom, washer, drains or utility tub. Remember, a basement bathroom or basement appliance can't utilize the force of gravity to help pump dirty water out of your house. So a sewage ejector pump is installed to force this dirty water out of your home.

But a sump pump takes care of discharging water from your sump pit, out of your house, to avoid flooding in your basement. It only pumps out ground water that collects in your sump pit - not dirty sewage or appliance water.

And if you'd like more information, on what a sump pump is, you can read: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sump_pump

Have you considered a stainless steel sump pump?

Do you have extreme water conditions and need a reliable heavy duty sump pump? You may want to consider a stainless steel sump pump for the job.

A stainless sump pump is an extremely durable sump pump that's manufactured with quality stainless steel to prevent rusting and ensure high performance.

Stainless steel sump pumps are submersible pumps, with a vertical float switch, and they're usually constructed with cast iron bases for durability and long life.

And you can see my #1 stainless steel sump pump pick: the Wayne 3/4 HP pump on Amazon.

Yes, a stainless steel sump pump usually comes with a higher price tag than a sump pump manufactured with thermoplastics. But if your budget can afford it, or you have demanding water conditions, you should really think about investing in one.

What is a column sump pump?

A column sump pump is another name for a pedestal sump pump. Pedestal sump pumps are often called column sump pumps  or upright sump pumps because they look like a thin, vertical column with a ball type head.

A column sump pump is another description for a pedestal sump pump.Column Sump Pump

A column sump pump has it's motor installed above the sump. The motor sits above the sump pit!This makes a column pump more easy to service, than a submersible pump.

And a column pump is generally less expensive than a submersible model, so their prices should be taken into consideration when you're choosing the right top sump pump.

And when you're comparing the top sump pump models, on the market, also keep in mind that pedestal or column sump pumps generally last longer than submersible sump pumps.

You can usually expect the top sump pumps that are pedestal style models to last up to 25 years! A long time. And, an average, a submersible sump pump will last about 7 to 15 years.

As you're comparing all the top sump pump styles &  models, it's important to keep these things in mind.

Now you have a lot of good information to help you choose the top sump pump.