Pedestal or Submersible Sump Pump?

Let’s talk about whether a pedestal or submersible sump pump is the right choice for you & your basement.

And you can see my #1 Wayne sump pump recommendation: the Wayne CDU800 on Amazon.

As you know, the two main types of sump pumps on the market are pedestal and submersible models. A pedestal style sump pump has been around longer than a submersible pump. But submersible sump pumps have become much more popular with homeowners.

I highly recommend the Wayne CDU800 sump pump because it can move up to 4,200 gallons of water, per hour, out of your basement, it has a cast iron base and it has a reliable vertical float switch.

The powerful 1/2 HP motor on this Wayne sump pump will give you peace of mind - and Wayne backs it up with a 3 year warranty!

The Wayne CDU800 also has a sealed bearing case that will limit the amount of maintenance you'll need to take care of. And the sealed bearings mean that its runs quieter.

Check Amazon's price on the Wayne CDU800 sump pump.

A submersible sump pump is installed in your sump pit – so it is fully immersed. Because a submersible sump pump works inside your sump pit, the running noise is dampened. So, a submersible sump pump will run much quieter than a pedestal model. Quiet motor operation is a big thing to consider when you’re wondering if a pedestal or submersible sump pump is right for you.

A pedestal sump pump will be installed to sit directly on your basement floor – above your sump basin. Because a pedestal pump is exposed, and not installed in the pit, it will make more noise while it’s running. And there is always the chance of it becoming damaged in your cellar by foot traffic, pets or children.

Costs | Pedestal or Submersible Sump Pump

pedestal or submersible sump pump

On average, the cost for a pedestal model will be less than a submersible sump pump. Pedestal sump pumps have fewer parts and are often times not as powerful as a submersible pump. As a general rule, pedestal pumps are more economical and that’s something you should consider when you’re trying to make up your mind between a pedestal or submersible sump pump.

I can recommend the Flotec FPPM3600D 1/3 HP Pedestal Sump Pump on Amazon.

This pedestal style sump pump will pump up to 3,480 gallons per hour (GPH), is designed with a non-clogging impeller and has a top screen inlet with 1.25” discharge. The Flotec FPPM3600D has both thermoplastic and cast iron construction with an 6 foot, 3 prong cord/plug.

And you can check Amazon’s price on the Flotec FPPM3600D Pedestal Sump Pump.

Installation | Pedestal or Submersible Sump Pump

Installation is an important thing to consider between a pedestal or submersible sump pump.  Although most homeowners that are handy would be able to install both types, a pedestal sump pump is really the easiest to install.

Because a pedestal sump pump is not lowered into the pit, it really only needs to be securely placed and braced on your basement floor.  While a submersible sump pump must be lowered into the pit.

Video | Sump Pump Maintenance

In case you wanted to get a clearer idea of the maintenance you'll need to do on a sump pump, this video will give you the basic facts:

Yes, you need to do yearly maintenance on any sump pump in order to make sure it's ready to work for you when there's a chance of flooding.

Working Life | Pedestal or Submersible Sump Pump

Also, I wanted to mention that pedestal pumps generally do last longer than submersible pumps. It’s not unusual to get 25-30 years out of a quality pedestal pump. To compare, many submersible pumps on the market will last about 7 - 15 years before you’ll have to replace it.

Of course, these are just averages and a lot will depend on how powerful your sump pump motor is and how often it needs to run to pump water out of your sump.

And if you'd like to read reviews of the best submersible sump pumps on the market, you can visit my submersible sump pump review page.

Repair | Pedestal or Submersible Sump Pump

Thinking about repairs for a pedestal or submersible sump pump? One advantage of a pedestal sump pump is that, because it sits on your cellar floor, it’s so easy to do repairs. You don’t have to pull it up out of the water to replace a part. Or test it.

Video | Repairing and Testing a Sump Pump

When you have a repair to do, on your sump pump, you'll want to also test it. You have to test it to make sure you can trust it to work when it's needed. Especially if you're not home and water starts to rise.

As you can see, it's easy to test your sump pump, so you have peace of mind.

And if you need to repair your submersible sump pump, you’ll need to remove any pit cover you might have, and pull it out of the water. And of course, you’ll need to put it back in the pit once you’re done your repairs.

It just takes a little more work to remove, repair, and reinstall a submersible unit.

Now you'll feel confident knowing whether you need to choose a pedestal or submersible sump pump.